A Fall In Property Value Can Be Recovered In A ‘Breach Of Contract’ Claim
9th July, 2013
In order to claim for losses in a ‘breach of contract’ claim, the loss must not be too ‘remote’, i.e. the loss that has occurred must have been reasonably foreseeable at the time that the contract was made.
In the recent Court of Appeal case of John Grimes Partnership Ltd v Gubbins , Mr Gubbins had instructed the John Grimes Partnership (‘JGP’) to design a road across a field that he had purchased for development. It was an express term of their agreement that the work would be finished by March 2007.
When the work was not completed by March 2007, Mr Gubbins instructed another firm who re-designed the road.
JGP issued proceedings against Mr Gubbins for unpaid invoices and Mr Gubbins counterclaimed for damages on the ground that JGP’s work had been defective. He also claimed that the failure to complete the work as promised had meant that there had been a reduction in the market value of the private residences to be built, as house prices had fallen between March 2007 and when the work was actually completed.
JGP were found to have breached the contract.
The Court implied a contractual term whereby JGP assumed responsibility for reasonably foreseeable losses. The Court found that JGP had known what Mr Gubbins had planned for the land and that delay brought the risk that the property market may move up or down. The loss in value, therefore, was deemed to be recoverable.
The advice coming from cases like this is that parties wishing to ensure they are not liable for a particular type of loss (eg a reduction in market value due to delay) should make sure that they expressly exclude them when making the contract.
For more information on this or any other contentious property matter please contact Beth Wheatley on 01244 405546 or email [email protected]
You might also be interested in...
22nd November, 2018
Family Law Partner Sandy Edwards believes there is. Next week, from 26 to 30 November, Resolution, an organisation of 6,500 family lawyers and other professionals, will be promoting “Good Divorce Week” which will focus on how separating and divorcing couples can put their children’s needs first and limit the impact of conflict. The week falls during the government’s divorce... Read More »
16th November, 2018
It is reported that a quarter of all complaints dealt with by the Legal Ombudsman revolve around costs. Therefore to avoid complaints and confusion, it is important to be clear from the outset. The new Transparency Rules (which the SRA have now confirmed will come into effect on 6 December 2018) require that accurate and relevant information is... Read More »
5th November, 2018
Aaron & Partners LLP has once again seen improved rankings in The Legal 500 – a comprehensive guide... Read More »