13th February, 2011
Court Takes Commonsense View of Delivery of Notice Clause
When a dispute arises under a contract and notices or other documents have to be delivered to the other side in the dispute, in order to avoid problems it is essential that these are delivered in accordance with the contract terms. This may seem obvious, but proceedings are quite frequently challenged on the basis that notices are incorrectly delivered and therefore invalid.
In a recent case involving a construction dispute, a claimant issued a notice referring the dispute to adjudication as provided by the contract. This was sent by post and, although incorrectly addressed, was received the next day. The defendant passed it on to its solicitor. The adjudicator found in the claimant’s favour and ordered the defendant to pay.
The defendant refused. The contract had specified that the notice of adjudication was to be delivered personally or by fax. The defendant argued that the adjudicator therefore had no jurisdiction over the dispute. The clause covering delivery also stated that it would be sufficient ‘to prove that personal delivery was made’.
The matter then went to court, where the claimant argued that as a matter of fact the defendant had received the notice, so the requirements of the delivery clause were satisfied. The court considered that the term ‘delivered personally’ meant that the notice was delivered by an appropriate individual representing the claimant to an appropriate individual representing the defendant. In the view of the court, the method of delivery did not matter. On the facts of the case, actual delivery to an appropriate person (the defendant’s solicitor) had occurred, so the delivery clause was satisfied.
In this case, the claim to resist the notice was unsuccessful because the court took a commonsense approach to the clause. This need not necessarily have been the case. The matter would never have gone to court had the notice also been delivered by fax.
“Whilst it is refreshing in this instance to see the court adopt a commonsense approach towards the method of serving notices, it would be foolhardy to become complacent when serving notices or documents pursuant to a contract” says Giles Williams. “To avoid any unnecessary stress and cost, strict compliance with the terms of the contract is always the best policy.”
Contact Giles Williams for advice on any commercial property or landlord and tenant matter on 01244 405580 or email him here
You might also be interested in...
9th August, 2022
Concerns surrounding the rising number of second homes has forced the Welsh Government to act. In July a... Read More »
2nd August, 2022
The Supreme Court has recently issued its long-awaited decision in the case of Harpur Trust v Brazel. This... Read More »