Signing a prenuptial agreement does not automatically prevent you from making an inheritance claim after your spouse’s death. Although its terms may influence the court’s decision, the court must consider whether the estate makes reasonable financial provision for you.
Understanding the relationship between prenups and inheritance claims is particularly important where an estate includes family wealth, property, business interests or trusts. In this article Contentious Trusts & Probate Senior Associate Danielle Blaylock explains how courts approach these agreements and what they could mean for your claim.
Can you make an Inheritance Act claim if you have a prenup?
Yes. A surviving spouse can still make an Inheritance Act claim after signing a prenuptial agreement. The court may take the agreement into account when deciding whether the Will or intestacy rules make reasonable financial provision for the surviving spouse. A prenuptial agreement is not automatically binding on death although it is a consideration in Inheritance Act claims.
Can a prenuptial agreement override the Inheritance Act 1975?
No. Some prenuptial agreements will seek to exclude claims under the Inheritance Act, but these clauses are unenforceable. The Court will still look at the surviving spouse or civil partner's needs and will consider what is reasonable in the circumstances. The Court will however look at the prenuptial agreement when considering what, if any, order to make and will always have in mind what is fair.
How do courts treat prenups when assessing a claim for reasonable financial provision?
When considering a spouse or civil partners award following an Inheritance Act claim, the Court will consider a divorce cross check. The Court would look at the payments the surviving party would have received on divorce not death. The purpose of a prenuptial agreement is usually to restrict this and agree a figure in advance.
What might lead the court to disregard a prenup in inheritance disputes?
The Court will look at the events leading up to the parties entering the prenuptial agreement such as when it was signed, if the parties had the benefit of legal advice, any pressure placed upon a party and disclosure of finances at that time. The Court will also look at life events during the marriage or civil partnership such as the arrival of children or if one party have given up work to support the other.
What role does financial need play when a prenup limits entitlement?
Financial need is at the heart of Inheritance Act claims however a spouse or civil partners claim is not limited to their maintenance. A party may seek to rely on the prenuptial agreement as a basis to limit any inheritance act claim however the Court will always look at the individuals financial need and all the circumstances. The terms of the prenuptial agreement, and any figures contained within will always be considered by the Court.
Can you challenge a will or estate distribution if you believe a prenup unfairly limits your provision?
Yes, a prenuptial agreement is not a bar to prevent an Inheritance Act claim however the Court will have regard to it.
Our guide to Inheritance Act claims explains who can apply, what the court considers and how long you have to bring a claim.
How do international assets affect prenuptial agreements and Inheritance Act claims?
The Deceased must have been domiciled in England and Wales in order to bring an Inheritance Act claim. They may have assets in different jurisdictions, however. Whilst the Court cannot make an order in respect of international assets, the value of those assets is considered when calculating the value of the Deceased's estate.
When dealing with international assets, you must consider the rule in that country and also the terms of the will. Some jurisdictions have forced heirship rules which need to be carefully considered.
Does a prenup protect business or trust assets from an Inheritance Act claim?
No. Business or Trust assets are not automatically protected however prenup can seek to ringfence those assets. One consideration however is whether the Deceased sought to hide those assets in such a structure. Whist the Court will consider the prenup, it still has ultimate discretion. It is advisable to regularly review your will as you increase your assets or property portfolio.
If you’re planning ahead, changes to your business interests or property portfolio are a good reason to check whether your Will needs updating.
Can a poorly drafted prenup lead to a successful Inheritance Act claim?
Whilst there is no direct link, if a prenuptial agreement is considered unenforceable during the parties' lifetime say for instance due to one party hiding assets, then the Court when applying the divorce cross check on death will look at the parties' assets as a whole and likely disregard any assets the prenuptial agreement seeks to exclude.
How are high-value or complex assets treated when a prenup is in place?
As with business and trust assets, the prenup may seek to exclude high value or particular assets, for example family wealth or property however on death, the entire value of the Deceased's estate is taken into consideration when the surviving spouse or civil partner seeks to bring an Inheritance Act Claim.
Speak to our Inheritance Act claims solicitors
If you’re unsure what a prenuptial agreement means for your inheritance after your spouse’s death, start by looking at what the agreement says alongside what you’re due to receive from the estate. This can be especially important where the estate includes business interests, trusts or property, as the value of those assets and what’s available to meet your financial needs may be difficult to establish.
Our Inheritance Act claims solicitors can advise on how the agreement may affect a claim and what financial provision may be reasonable in your circumstances.
Whether you’re considering a claim or responding to one, our Contentious Trusts & Probate team can review the prenup and the provision made by the estate, explain how the agreement could affect the claim and advise you on your next steps.
Key Contact
Danielle Blaylock
Contentious Trusts & Probate Senior Associate Solicitor
Danielle is a Senior Associate Solicitor within our Contentious Trusts and Probate team. She specialises in contentious probate disputes and has a particular interest in cases relating to capacity and the farming sector.