Aaron & Partners has launched a landmark Upper Tribunal appeal concerning the classification of electric excavators under UK trade tariffs, in a case that could have significant implications for the future of green construction technology.
We have filed the legal challenge on behalf of LiuGong Machinery UK, a manufacturer and distributor of construction equipment, following a previous trade remedies decision which brought certain electric models within the scope of anti-dumping duties. These duties add additional trade tariffs to regular customs charges when goods are imported from certain countries.
The appeal, which is the first of its kind in this emerging post-Brexit area, questions whether it was reasonable to treat zero-emission machinery in the same way as conventional fossil fuel-driven equipment under the current trade remedies regime. The outcome could shape how clean construction technologies are treated under UK trade rules in the future.
The case follows a wider investigation by the Trade Remedies Authority (TRA) into imported excavators, following an application by JCB seeking an investigation into previous sales of excavators imported from the People’s Republic of China. Following that investigation, the Secretary of State approved a recommendation for duties to apply to certain imported excavators.
LiuGong Machinery UK is now challenging the inclusion of electric excavators within those measures, arguing that the electric excavators were not previously imported and therefore fall outside the intended scope of the regime. The appeal also argues that electric excavators are technologically and environmentally distinct, justifying different treatment.
Layla Barke-Jones, Dispute Resolution Partner at Aaron & Partners, who is leading the appeal, said:
"This appeal raises an important and very practical question, how should the UK’s existing trade rules apply to new, low-carbon technology and what practical measures should apply to ensure the purpose of trade tariffs are best served?"
"Electric excavators are fundamentally different from traditional diesel machines. They are part of the construction sector’s transition to cleaner infrastructure and lower emissions. The issue now is whether it’s right to treat them exactly the same as conventional machinery for anti-dumping purposes, despite those differences."
The appeal to the Upper Tier Tribunal, the specialist judicial body responsible for reviewing trade remedies decisions, represents the first opportunity for judicial scrutiny of the classification of imported electric excavators under the UK’s trade remedies framework. The case could also help inform how future clean-technology products are assessed under the regime.
Aaron & Partners’ work on the matter builds on extensive engagement with the TRA, alongside detailed submissions demonstrating that electric excavators differ materially from other imported machinery in terms of end use, technology, manufacture, market dynamics, cost structure and policy context.
The appeal process is now underway and is expected to continue over the coming months.
Need to Talk to Someone?
Use the form to send us some details about your matter and one of our experts will get in touch, or you can call us using the number below.
